“Primacy of Conscience” debunked

Every time we recite the creed, we proclaim our belief “in the Holy Catholic Church.” Every time we receive Holy Communion, we count ourselves faithful members of Christ’s unified body. Every time we renew our baptismal vows, as we will this coming Easter Sunday, we re-commit ourselves to Christ and his Church.

So why is it that so many well-intentioned, faithful Catholics, openly reject the Church and dissent from her teachings; whether over a hot-button issue like gay marriage, abortion, or women in the priesthood or something less “political”, like whether lay people should be permitted to serve in this or that ministry, or if certain “ministries” should even exist!

We all know at least one mass-going Catholic…

…who is just hanging on for the day that the “homophobic” bishops will finally give up their condemnation of gay marriage.
…who deeply desires that abortion remain an option for victims of rape and women who suffer through difficult and dangerous pregnancies.
…who wishes the Church would be less exclusive and recognize the subjective truth of all world religions!
…who voted for Obama, believes in Karma, is vegetarian for the sake of animals’ feelings and loves liturgical dance… and the list could go on.

Such unabashed dissent is arguably one of the greatest problems the Church faces today.

And it’s awful! Not only does it cause serious scandal, remaining Catholic by name while desecrating the truth of the faith with submission to worldly thinking and practice; it also seriously compromises one’s relationship with Christ, the bridegroom of the Holy Church.

Imagine you were friends with a married couple, but over time you came to dislike, perhaps even hate the wife. Surely, your relationship with the husband – who still faithfully adored and treasured his spouse – would suffer. Your friendship would undoubtedly change if you rejected the person with whom he was one flesh through marriage. So the same goes for Christ and His bride, the Church. You cannot love  Jesus completely, without loving His Church completely.

Primacy of Conscience

A deep-seeded root of this problem is a misunderstanding of “primacy of conscience.” Lots of dissenting Catholics point to the Catechism’s instruction that “A human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience” (CCC 1800). And so they say, “My conscience tells me that gays should have the right to marry…that women should have the right to choose,” etc.  However, many fail to acknowledge the Church’s complementary teaching that one’s conscience is not the final arbiter of morality; Christ’s Divine Law is. But they defend their rejections of the doctrines of the faith with an obvious misunderstanding that the Church has somehow endorsed their freedom to act against her.

The true nature of our conscience is that it serves as a situational alarm system. In any particular situation, you are obligated to acknowledge and act upon “red flags” to avoid sin and evildoing. For example, if you are in a burning building, an alarm system should tell you to quickly evacuate to stay safe. Logical, right? However, let’s say the building you’re in catches on fire and the alarms don’t go off. Does it mean that there’s no danger? That it’s safe to stay inside? Of course not.

You must maintain your alarm system! You must inform your conscience by seeking to truly understand Divine Law. The Catechism says, “A well-formed conscience is upright and truthful” (1798).  As Catholics, we acknowledge one truth in the faith. Just as the sky cannot be both blue and green, we cannot label something both sinful and non-sinful. This misunderstood “primacy of conscience” says nay, it can be both. Someone may hear the alarm bells ringing, while another hears nothing, but the danger of sin definitively exists there, or it does not – not both. It’s impossible!

If  you trust that the Holy Catholic Church was able to carry on the succession of the priesthood, so that on Sunday, you have a Holy Mass to attend, which is not just a worship service at some fellowship community church of the mountain valley forest of living water, but a miraculous sacrifice in which Christ actually becomes present before you in the Blessed Sacrament, you must trust that the Church – without which you would have no living Christ to sustain you – is sacred, holy and TRUE.

And she will help you get to Heaven, if you trust her.


5 thoughts on ““Primacy of Conscience” debunked

  1. Kathy, I agree with you on everything except your comment of being vegetarian for the sake of the animals’ feelings. Many legitimate, well-respected studies have proven that animals have feelings, and when one follows a plant based diet for the sake of lessening the violence of slaughter, that can hardly be against Church teachings. Can you tell me where in the Catechism it says you must eat meat? I mean, even St. Francis himself was a vegetarian.

    • We observe fasting and abstinence days for the purpose of doing penance. St. Francis of Assisi was a vegetarian for the purpose of doing penance. The Carmelite order observes complete abstinence from meat unless the health of a nun requires the eating of meat. The Minim Friars (founded by St. Francis of Paola) observe a perpetual Lent. Nowhere in the Catechism does it say we must eat meat. On the contrary, the Church commends penance and enjoins it upon us to fast and abstain on the days appointed. Many Catholics observe perpetual abstinence from meat, or sweets, or any other type of food, but for the purposes of mortification. Eastern Rite Catholics observe an even stricter schedule of fast and abstinence days.

      Others abstain from meat or some other food due to allergies or serious health issues — many cancer patients follow a strict vegan diet and often times it has saved their lives to do so. I’m personally acquainted with several people who have pretty much reversed cancer and other serious health issues by following an 80% raw food diet and complete elimination of meat, dairy and refined sugar. Nobody is arguing with that.

      You missed Katy’s point entirely. One should abstain from meat for the purpose of mortification; for penance, or in combination with working to eliminate serious illness. If you are abstaining from meat because of a dangerous New Age belief, then your motivations for abstaining from meat are not correct. You may not like that, but it is the truth.

  2. Hi Katy! It was so nice to have you and Joe as parishoners for the time you lived here. All the best in your new home and parish. Superb writing! I’m looking forward to keeping in touch via email and blogging. 🙂

  3. I check your blog several times a week to see if there have been any more updates. I am extremely curious as to your opinion of Pope Francis. I can’t help but wonder if the absence of recent posts has been due to shock or disbelief at the direction Pope Francis is taking the church. It seems to me that the direction that Pope Francis is taking the church stands in direction contradiction to what you have advocated in many of your posts. Just curious as I have been lurking and reading your posts for a while. Hope all is well!

    • Hi, Jerry. Thanks for reaching out! I’m so sorry I’ve been offline for some time now. It hasn’t been due to shock over the new pope, but rather, a big move, job adjustment, and some other news that I’ll be sharing in upcoming posts. I have a new post going up this week, so keep your eye out! As for our new Holy Father, I’m not certain he is “taking” the Church in any direction which actually contradicts my conservative beliefs. Of course, I would have preferred another more traditional pontiff, but my preference is no match for the Holy Spirit, whom I trust is guiding our Church. My greater fear is liberal Catholics – as well as those outside the faith – continuing to misconstrue his words and actions to advance their own anti-Catholic agenda. I continue to pray that our Church leaders, including Pope Francis, teach with clarity to avoid such misinterpretation, although it’s sometimes unavoidable with such bloodthirsty opponents of the faith. God help us to be ambassadors of the Truth!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s